top of page
Search

We live in patriarchy

  • James Miller
  • Jun 22
  • 2 min read

Updated: Jun 27

Cambridge Dictionary: Patriarchy (n.) – a society controlled by men in which they use their power to their own advantage.


1 Who Actually Holds the Levers?

  1. Politics

    • Western legislatures are still male-heavy (≈65 % men in Europe; ≈73 % in the U.S.).

    • Women nevertheless chair key committees, run major ministries, and hold the European Commission and ECB presidencies.

    • Head-count ≠ agenda control: those male-majority chambers routinely pass laws explicitly framed as benefiting women (e.g., EU Pay-Transparency Directive, Violence Against Women Act expansions).

  2. Corporate boardrooms

    • Roughly 9 out of 10 Fortune 500 CEOs are male.

    • Yet boards chase ESG scores, female-quota targets, and brand campaigns centred on “empowering women.”


The pattern: a numerical male skew among decision-makers, but not an observable pro-male policy bias.


2 Do Ordinary Men Reap Group-Level Advantages?

Domain

Outcome

Does it favour men?

Criminal justice

Sentencing studies show women receive ~25–30 % lighter penalties than similarly situated men.

No

Family courts

Mothers win sole custody ≈80 % of the time.

No

Workplace risk

>90 % of occupational deaths are male.

No

Education

Women earn ~60 % of all university degrees in Anglophone countries.

No

Health funding

Breast-cancer research still outspends prostate-cancer research 2–3 : 1 despite similar mortality.

No

If the system were patriarchal by definition, we would expect the inverse of every line in that table.


3 Where the “Patriarchy” Frame Breaks Down

  1. Elite ≠ Class Solidarity. Male executives or senators share education, income, and network ties with elite women—much more than with working-class men. Sex is not the operative glue.

  2. Policy Outputs Clash with Patriarchy Claims. Laws and budgets are skewing toward female-specific benefits, while male-specific crises (suicide, homelessness, drop-out rates) draw scant political urgency.

  3. Benefit Pathway Is Missing. A male-controlled institution that delivers neither preferential sentencing nor better health outcomes for men fails the “advantage” clause in the definition.


A More Accurate Label

What we actually see is elite dominance with a residual male head-count surplus. Call it an oligarchy, a managerial class, the “Davos set”—but don’t call it patriarchy unless:

  • virtually all seats of power are male and

  • those seats are used to lift men as a group above women.


Modern Western data satisfy neither condition. The word “patriarchy” therefore obscures more than it explains; it smuggles in an assumption of collective male benefit that the evidence simply does not support.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page